Understood. Given the practical limitations in tracking data, if that is the basis for your decision, I have no objections. However, since there is still no clear information regarding compensation for DeFi participants, we must also consider this point; otherwise, distortions may arise later.
Apologies — that was my misunderstanding.
I fully agree with @Gaius_sama 's opinion. The approximately 200M ASTR was protected by the Astar Foundation and the community, and should be returned directly to nsASTR holders. It is not an asset that Neemo can use at its own discretion.
Here is a recap of the current situation:
- ASTR protected in the treasury: 204,283,546.036 ASTR
- Chunk1 amount returned to users: 26,783,546.036 ASTR
- Remaining ASTR available for nsASTR redemption: 177,500,000 ASTR
- nsASTR eligible for redemption: 204,375,104.425 nsASTR
- Total ASTR required for redemption: 226,856,365.912 ASTR
- ASTR shortfall: 49,356,365.912 ASTR
- (*ASTR needed for redemption based on pre-hack snapshot: 175,796,365.912 ASTR)
As shown, there is a shortfall of approximately 50M ASTR.
If redemption is carried out based on a pre-hack snapshot and DeFi users (likely primarily liquidity providers) are handled through a separate process, it would be possible to complete the repayment immediately — though it’s unclear whether such a decision would gain consensus.
Also, I had overlooked it earlier, but could you clarify what the “Discount Ratio” refers to?
Why was this specific percentage chosen?