Proposal to Delist Project HaHa Coin from dApp Staking

Governance
1

Proposal to Delist Project HaHa Coin from dApp Staking

Submitted by: Astar Community Council Member Mouthmouth68
Date: 2025/10/04

Summary

This post serves as an official proposal from the Astar Community Council to delist HaHa Coin from the Astar Network dApp Staking Portal. The proposal outlines the rationale behind the suggested delisting and invites the community to review and provide feedback in accordance with governance procedures.

The primary reason for this proposal is due to inactivity and failure to meet performance criteria.

Project Information

:cross_mark: Reason for Delisting Proposal

The Astar Community Council recommends the delisting of HaHa Coin for the following reasons:

  • Inactivity: The project has not shown any activity since April 2025.

  • Non-compliance: Failure to comply with the Code of Conduct guidelines and expectations set forth by the Astar Community Council, including but not limited to:

    • Team do not respond to ACC resquests for informations
    • Project seems to have been inactive for serveral months already

:bar_chart: Supporting Evidence

  • No update from the team on their TG, X or on the forum since April 1st 2025

  • Project team do not answers ACC nor other Astar represntants requests for information

:loudspeaker: Community Engagement & Feedback

The Council encourages all community members and stakeholders to provide their input on this proposal within the next 7 days. Feedback can be submitted as a comment in this post thread.

:white_check_mark: Next Steps

  1. Open community discussion and feedback period for 7 days.

  2. Formal onchain vote

  3. Enactment of delisting if approved.

  4. Notification to HaHa Coin (on forum and X) and final removal from the dApp staking list.

For questions, concerns, feedback, and/ or counter-proposals, please reach out via here in the comments section on Astar.

:monkey_face: Mouthmouth68

Astar Community Council
@Community_Council

10 Likes
2

Hello. Thank you for sharing this proposal and thank you for your detailed investigation.

I have been HAHA ambassador since probably the first days of the project and supporting the HAHA team, community. I’m also an Astar token hodler and supporter. So I will try to explain the situation of HAHA.

Most of us know that HAHA was launched during Astar zkEVM gold days and gained good momentum and relevance supporting Astar ecosystem. The HAHA team core values were always integrity, transparency and openness to the community.

In the past months I noticed VD from the HAHA team suddenly deleted his telegram account (we loose contact and I do not know the reasons). After that tora was in charge of the HAHA group.

On February 12

The HAHA team decided to burn all team HAHA allocations and announced in the community.

This below is a resume of the post:

(

:astronaut: How much did the team take in payments?
:money_bag: ZERO. NADA. NOTHING.
:fire: How much did we burn?
:100: The full team allocation: 1% of the total supply—GONE FOREVER!

:gem_stone: We didn’t take a single $HAHA from the team allocation.
:gem_stone: We didn’t dump on holders.
:gem_stone: We worked FOR FREE because MAMA’S GOOD KIDS DON’T DUMP!

:rocket: Check the TXN & witness the :fire::fire::fire:
:backhand_index_pointing_right:Soneium Network transaction 0x04534ff7f5fcdbae05abe181afbdd9c1434c5fbf00ec82c4d03190ebc165044c | Blockscout

)
Screenshot

Screenshot_20251005_123956_Telegram
Screenshot_20251005_123956_Telegram720×1600 230 KB

After that team continued being leading by tora and reaching almost 1m staked astr and the astr rewards from dApp Staking were used to buy back and burn HAHA. Team always worked 100% for the community for free and doesn’t take any profit.

Then after some days/weeks Tora suddenly deleted his telegram account( We do not know the reasons and lose any contact). Maybe a personal problem I guess but I am not sure and do not know the real cause.

I noticed the ownership of the HAHA telegram group was transferred to @Matt

Probably Tora did this before leaving without contacting us, I do not know.

Looking forward:

Right now I would like to continue supporting HAHA coin project because I believe it has huge potential and I have some plans in mind to support Astar Ecosystem. Thank for your attention to this matter. Dennis.

1 Like
3

Thank you for the proposal, and thank you @Dennis for sharing the information.

Regardless of the background, I believe delisting is the appropriate action given the current situation.
If they resume activity in the future, they can simply reapply at that time.
As things stand now, there’s no convincing reason to keep the listing active.

2 Likes
4

Hello there, yes HAHA was transferred to me. However, I haven’t been contacted or messaged by Tora, so I’m not entirely sure about the situation.

The community, and especially the team, have been inactive, with no visible progress or signs of a HAHA revival. Therefore, I believe delisting is the right decision at this point.

If there’s ever a renewed effort or push to revive the project, it could always be reconsidered or discussed again, possibly alongside UCG.

1 Like
5

I support the proposal due to similar reasoning already mentioned above.

6

Hey everyone, it’s Dennis here, Real_Dennis_S_F on X and the Astar Forum.

Updates on HAHA.

CA: Soneium Network token details | Blockscout

2988 holders

37T HAHA & 95.8K ASTR on QuickSwap Algebra pool aprox $5k liquidity.

HAHA token contract is still on-chain active as you could check on Soneium explorer.

Contract Address: Scanned and has +90 safety score.

Screenshot_20251009_212958_Chrome
Screenshot_20251009_212958_Chrome720×690 64.5 KB

Moving forward.

As one of the original ambassadors for HAHA Coin, I’ve been riding with this project since its early days, back when it was pumping on Astar zkEVM with that community-first vibe: transparency, burns, and real support for the ecosystem. We hit nearly 1M ASTR staked at peak, and those rewards went straight into buybacks and burns—no team cuts, just pure community wins. But then it all stalled. VD and Tora dipped out without a trace, deleting their Telegram accounts, leaving us hanging. No updates since April 1, 2025, and now this delisting proposal from the ACC hits on October 4, calling out the inactivity and Code of Conduct slip-ups. I totally get the frustration—crypto moves fast, and ghosting the community isn’t cool. Astar zkEVM itself got deprecated on March 31, 2025, and fully shut down April 1, so that explains some of the radio silence as we scrambled to migrate. HAHA’s now live on Soneium Blockchain, which feels like a natural pivot to keep the meme magic alive without losing the zk roots. But delisting HAHA from dApp Staking would kill the momentum: staked ASTR gets redirected, rewards dry up, and we’d lose that portal visibility just when revival’s possible. The feedback window closes October 11—that’s only two days out from today, October 9. If we don’t push back, it heads to an on-chain vote on Astar Gov, and poof, it’s gone. As an active ambassador with real skin in the game (ASTR holder, no dumps, all volunteer hours), I’m stepping up to lead the charge. My ask: Let’s avoid delisting, transfer Telegram ownership to me (it’s with @Matt now), and redirect those staking rewards to a transparent multi-sig under my watch for burns, marketing, and incentives that actually build value. No BS, everything on-chain and public. I’ve already dropped some context in the thread, but we need volume—stakers, holders, Astar crew—to pile on. Here’s the straight-up plan to make this happen. I’ll kick it off myself, but your voices amplify it. Let’s turn HAHA into a comeback story.

Phase 1: Hit the Feedback Hard and Build the Case (Today through October 11) First off, I’m expanding my forum reply right here with the full revival details. Picture this: For Q4 2025, we’ll relaunch socials on X and Telegram, run a quick contract audit on Soneium, and host AMAs tying HAHA back to Astar’s broader ecosystem—maybe even cross-chain hooks for stakers.

Then Q1 2026 ramps up with partnerships, liquidity pools funded by rewards, and fresh utilities like meme NFTs or yield boosts.

I’ll nominate myself as interim lead, with rewards flowing to a multi-sig wallet (me plus two community picks) split 50% ASTR & HAHA burns, 30% marketing pushes, 20% holder incentives.

I am requesting that Telegram handoff to me as the obvious next steward—especially since Tora’s exit left it in limbo. I’ll commit to a compliance pact, full transparency, and if we dodge delisting, updating the dApp operator to me with any KYC you need. For rewards, they’d redirect seamlessly to fuel the revival without a hitch.

“Revive HAHA on Soneium? Hell yes.” If Telegram flips to me, we’ll pin updates and poll the group. I’ll even bump the original HAHA proposal thread for that historical flex.
I’ll lock in activity fast. Update Telegram and X bios with Soneium links, post weekly recaps—progress, Astar news crossovers, the works.

Every reward mmoves, Wallet addresses out in the open on Blockscout, no secrets. The roadmap gets fleshed out and shared wide: Month 1, social blast-off and audits; Months 2-3, campaigns and pools to pull in Soneium liquidity; Month 4 on, integrations that nod back to Astar, like staking airdrops or builder collabs. It’s all geared to Astar’s growth vibes.

ACC for the operator switch and multi-sig setup. Old team ghosts back? We negotiate fair. Quick security audit first, always. Long haul: Weekly metric drops (stakes, engagement), quarterly ACC check-ins. No repeats on inactivity.

HAHA’s the mother of memes for a reason—fun, resilient, community-owned. Soneium’s our fresh start post-zkEVM shutdown, but Astar staking’s the heartbeat. Don’t let it flatline. If you’re feeling this, comment now, DM me thoughts. Together, we flip the script. Let’s go!

7

I am happy to see your passion. Still i i am favour of a delisting, because all this could have been clarified very much in advance and not when delisting is threatened. Yet i would gladly support a relisting once all these changes get tangible and visible. Personally and as an Investor i am no fan of memecoins at all, but i can see the community value it brings to have something like this in an eco.

Wishing best of luck and hope to see you around more often

2 Likes
8

In the past I didn’t believe in memecoins but is impressive how the memecoins are huge impactful making Blockchains grow. Solana gained lot of users due it’s memecoins seasons and now BNB chain used the same strategy to position BNB as one of the largest cap crypto with almost 130B market cap. Still during this crash is being traded above 1000usd. I think that doing the right things memecoins can be a powerful tool. We also experience a significant growth during the zkEVM’s HAHA airlyft.one campaign bringing to our chain important amount of users and generating a lot of on chain activity, we alsoraised almost 3m HAHA market cap at the peak and positioned Astar’s zkEVM on X as trending with our constantly marketing campaigns hashtaging Astar zkEVM Astar #1000xgem, etc. Crypto is a huge ecosystem were every factor play an important role. Imagine all the success we can achieve positioning HAHA as the main memecoin on Soneium ecosystem and doing huge marketing campaigns with the experience we have built from the past successes, imagine that our comunity organic growth from almost 100 users to 2000 in 1-2 weeks after HAHA was launched, now with Soneium I seen tremendous potential to bring billions of users and spread awareness of Astar as the heart of our ecosystems. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Dennis

9

Update X Account:

10
11

With Meme being inactive since May I think this suggestion is reasonable.

12

@Community_Council @Finance_Committee

Updates on Telegram.:backhand_index_pointing_down:

https://t.me/HAHACoinASTAR

I would like to express my gratitude to All participants in this proposal.

HAHA is here to stay, @tora0515 and @VD545 have left the Telegram. But I am here, We are here together with the same goal: Make Astar great & build the web 3 future for Billions, and we’re gonna make this happen! We’re building since the first day for Astar and Astar is where our hearts beat. Together we’re stronger. I am a humble ASTR holder who wants to help. Transparency is key: Currently I am holding 0 HAHA, 0 money interest. But I strongly believe that under my lead HAHA can be huge impactful to Soneium & Astar ecosystem growth positioning HAHA as the main memecoin The Mother of Memes. HAHA in Japanese means mama which makes the Mother of Memes a powerful concept since Astar is leading l1 blockchain in Japan.

What I would like to do if HAHA dapps-staking is transfer under my new team:

  1. Burn All ASTR previous/pending dapps-staking reward which are not under my control and are in control of the previous team address.
  2. Create a new multi-sig address for dapps-staking with me and 2 team members ( Astar ecosystem agent member + community council) for management.

Use of Dapps-staking rewards:

  1. Launch a marketing campaign with airlyft.one to spread awareness and bring new users to Soneium benefiting Astar since our lps on QuickSwap are paired with ASTR on the Algebra pool, generating and increasing constantly tx activities.
  2. Boost our new X Account to premium enhancing the reeach. 2025 Q4 target 10k/new users on Telegram and followers on X. 2026 Q1 25k…
  3. Position HAHA as tier 1 on dapps-staking (long term).
  4. Monthly Reporting our achievements here on the forum.
  5. Add liquidity on Uniswap and Hydration bridging Soneium with Polkadot ecosystem.
  6. Periodically burn 10% of astr obtained from our revenues collection over all protocols. ( Uniswap, Hydration,QuickSwap and so on…)
  7. Create a strategic reserve assets for HAHA to guarantee our sustainability long-term. ( assets in the strategy to be disclosed in the future) and guarantee that our revenues are more than our spends.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. Dennis

Note: (Amil_Gaoul on the forum is my other username, I had to post with the other user(Amil_Gaoul) because the new user(Dennis)is only allowed 3 post replies in this forum post. (Amil_Gaoul and Dennis are the same person/users)Please kindly read this to avoid confusion. Thank you

13

Hi everyone,

I understand that abondon of the project made it difficulte to go forwards. But as mentioned, by @PolkaWarrior it is surprizing to see that actor start to move only on thread of being delisted.

That is said, i’m personnaly not closed to keep HAHA dApp ongoing (this is my personal opinion denuaed from eny personal interest as i do not hold any HaHa token).

As mentioned, meme can be a powerfull tool to attract attention and new user to Astar and Soneium and this is in itself a reasonable reason to keep HaHa on dApp staking.

Furthermore, even if I’m not fond of meme coin, i’ve seen the effort put by the team to reach this concept/desing and I find it honestly fun.

I however want to see a proper plan aiming to make HAHA more financially independant (over time) from dApp staking and promot HaHa and Astar community in a constructive and long terme fashion.

Hi everyone,

I understand that the departure of some team members (@VD545 and @tora0515) has made it difficult for the project to move forward. However, as previously mentioned by @PolkaWarrior, it is quite surprising to see activity resume only when the project faces the possibility of being delisted. I hope it was only the spark that stirs the hive for the remaining team whom needed to grab their courage to take over HaHa as project face a move or die situation.

That said, I personally remain open to the idea of keeping the HaHa dApp active — and I want to be clear that this opinion is my own only, not the ACC, and is entirely objective, as I hold no HaHa tokens or personal stake in the project.

Memes can indeed be a powerful tool to attract attention and bring new users to Astar and Soneium, which in itself is a valid reason to consider maintaining HaHa within the dApp Staking program.

Furthermore, while I’m not particularly a fan of meme coins, I do recognize and appreciate the effort and creativity the team has put into the project’s concept and design — it’s a genuinely fun and engaging idea, supported by a catchy and memorable slogan.

However, moving forward, I would like to see a clear and realistic plan (short/medium/long term) outlining how HaHa intends to become progressively more financially independent from dApp Staking, while continuing to promote both the HaHa project and the Astar community in a constructive and long-term manner.

2 Likes
14

I will address this one as I think could be one of the major preoccupation of our community.

I have learned in my experience that sometimes (and I say sometimes not always) we should let things happen and see the progress, never quit and act in the right moment when is paramount important to act. When I entered as ambassador I trusted 100% in VD and Tora, I tried to not push too much things by my side, because I always trusted them, they did an exceptional great job positioning HAHA from 9k market cap at the beginning to almost 3millions at the peak in the HAHA liquidity pool QuickSwap on the Astar zkEVM currently deprecated. They did a great job, we also did it together, we have a brilliant community. After Soneium was launched, the pool was migrated to Soneium, I suggested QuickSwap as major dex, and we chose it, in that moment we didn’t have Uniswap yet of course. I noticed the community activity started to decrease, I tried to do something but my telegram ambassador account was always restricted to only post messages in the group and links, in spite of that I continued supporting the project trying to do my best with what I had available and never gave up and I won’t. VD and Tora leaving the telegram group called my attention immediately and I acted immediately when I was aware of the situation reporting it to @Juminstock . As an Astar Community Member my # 1 priority is to protect Astar ecosystem and ASTR holders in which I am included. But as a HAHA ambassador my priority # 1 is save the project. Because of that, I decided to move forward and take the lead of HAHA. My plan: I shared it in my previous reply. Please kindly read it and give me feedbacks. Let’s rebuild the trust and move forward. Remember: Together We ARE STRONGER. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Dennis

1 Like
15

It concerns me to see action being taken only at the brink of delisting. We could end up with a project drifting aimlessly for months. The team abandoning it and leaving it to “whoever wants to take over” is not a professional approach — neither for the project’s holders nor for Astar Network as a whole.

I’d like to see the statistics on holders, on-chain interactions, and what the project has actually contributed to Astar over the past quarter.

16

If the project leader has no skin in the game, why would anyone else have? I’m sorry, but I don’t see it as reasonable to proceed with the listing

The structure of the model looks solid, but it seems more like a new listing request for a new project under new leadership. The most reasonable approach would be to delist the project and reapply later, demonstrating on-chain activity and the reasons why the new team has earned the opportunity to join the dApp Staking program again.

If the results are positive for Astar, the proposal will certainly be approved. However, the experience of abandoning the project has left a very negative impression — and the overall community sentiment toward it is one of unprofessionalism.

17

[quote=“pitcoin777, post:15, topic:9036”]

It concerns me to see action being taken only at the brink of delisting. We could end up with a project drifting aimlessly for months. The team abandoning it and leaving it to “whoever wants to take over” is not a professional approach — neither for the project’s holders nor for Astar Network as a whole.

[/quote]

This was explained in my previous post, :folded_hands: please kindly read :folded_hands:. Tora and VD left telegram but, I am still active ( I am Dennis, I had to use this user because in the forum Dennis new User had a 3 post limitations). I also agree with you that tora and vd suddenly leaving the telegram without talking to me and the community is not a professional approach. The positive thing is that I am here to stay since the first day as a HAHA ambassador and now to continue with what we built as the leader. HAHA is still a baby project, still needs a leadership to survive and thrive.

[quote=“pitcoin777, post:16, topic:9036”]

If the project leader has no skin in the game, why would anyone else have? I’m sorry, but I don’t see it as reasonable to proceed with the listing

[/quote]

Holding 0 HAHA as I stated before doesn’t mean that I have no skin in the project. This means all the contrary: Holding 0 HAHA and being here 100 % in representation of HAHA demonstrates my full 100% commitment with the project roots beyond the money interest.

[quote=“pitcoin777, post:16, topic:9036”]

The structure of the model looks solid, but it seems more like a **new listing request** for a new project under new leadership. The most reasonable approach would be to **delist the project** and reapply later, demonstrating on-chain activity and the reasons why the new team has earned the opportunity to join the dApp Staking program again.

[/quote]

Thank you for taking time reading the plan I built for saving HAHA and positioning as the leading Memecoin on Soneium and Astar ecosystem. However this is not a new listing request, this is a request to transfer the old reward dapps-staking address to a new multi-sig address under my lead composed by me and two team members ( 1 ecosystem agent + 1 comunity council). Burning previous old team address pending ASTR rewards.

I don’t see the need of delisting for the motive on chain activity as you stated before since HAHA continues producing on chain activity on the Algebra pool. You can check on Soneium blocks explorer for our ca: 0xA8FeAae65C44B458A16Ea4E709036A2ee85d073A

+2800 token Holders

Algebra pool on QuickSwap: 95k ASTR + 37T HAHA (aprox 4000 usd total).

1T HAHA price = 67 usd aprox (1% aprox of max supply).

HAHA token contract has +90% safety socore I showed a previous analysis on a previous post.

Additionally HAHA Algebra pool on QuickSwap (HAHA/ASTR) is constantly producing txs on Soneium, this is 100% verifiable on chain.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Dennis

18

Hi everyone :waving_hand:t2:
As others have already mentioned here, I’m also a bit surprised to see a partial reactivation from the team only after the delisting proposal was posted on the forum.

I’ve never been against the HAHA project, since I believe that even a meme coin — if managed actively and with good organization — can bring value to the Astar ecosystem. So, in principle, I find its presence in the dApp Staking program legitimate.

However, when a project remains inactive for so many months, I think it’s fair to propose a delisting.
That said, it could still make sense to give the team a short additional period to present a clear and detailed reactivation plan, with solid motivations and an actionable roadmap that can convince the community.

As of today, from my personal point of view, I would be in favor of the delisting — mainly because if there had truly been an intention to revive the project, the team probably wouldn’t have waited for a delisting proposal to take action.
That being said, I’m open to changing my mind if the team can genuinely demonstrate their commitment and a concrete plan to bring the project back to life in a consistent and serious way.

2 Likes
19

@Amil_Gaoul It’s good to see your proactivity and intention, but what’s the point of trying to revive a memecoin that no longer has any impact?

I read all your justification here but I don’t see a rational reason to keep HAHA Coin within the dApp Staking program.

1 Like
20

Thank you Carlos. I appreciate your time reading all my posts in this topic. Thank you.

Important

I have detected potential risks on HAHA contract and associated hodlers and liquidity pool. Below is a resume of the researched made by AI assistant :backhand_index_pointing_down:

Overview of HAHA Token on Soneium HAHA ticker HAHA is a meme coin originally launched on Astar zkEVM described as Astars OG MEME coin and the Mother of Memes. It migrated to Soneium an Ethereum Layer 2 blockchain developed by Sony Block Solutions Labs using Optimisms OP Stack in mid January 2025. The token is now available for trading and liquidity provision on QuickSwap Soneium deployment. Based on blockchain explorers social media and web searches HAHA shows characteristics of a community driven meme token with positive engagement but carries standard risks for low cap meme coins like volatility illiquidity and hype dependency. No evidence of scams rugs or security vulnerabilities specific to HAHA was found. However general Soneium phishing warnings highlight caution needs. Contract Details HAHA Token 0xA8FeAae65C44B458A16Ea4E709036A2ee85d073A This is an ERC20 token contract on Soneium. It focuses on memes staking rewards and burns to reduce supply. Total supply is 100000000000000 tokens 100 trillion max with decimals 18. Circulating supply is about 97.3 trillion after burns. Name is Mother of Memes symbol HAHA. The contract is verified on Blockscout with no suspicious code reports. Ownership is not renounced owner remains the creator allowing potential changes like minting. No honeypot backdoors or blacklists noted. Transaction history shows normal activity like transfers and LP additions post migration. Liquidity Pool Algebra Pool on QuickSwap 0x7daf3aaf21067d5FEb6415E2898c29cEDAC1C2Ed This is the liquidity pool for HAHA paired with ETH or stablecoin on QuickSwap Soneium. It was whitelisted in late January 2025. Liquidity was added around January 28 2025 via QuickSwap. The pool is unlocked isUnlocked true meaning positions can be withdrawn anytime increasing rug risk. No lock via timelock or burn address evident. Reserves support low volume trades but liquidity is low leading to slippage risks. Creator Address 0xeA9c9404422E2e09b5e4872A6FEa1311Fef46c0D This address deployed the HAHA contract. It holds exactly 10000000000000 HAHA tokens 10 percent of max supply from initial mint. Transactions include airdrops distributions and LP interactions no dumps or scam patterns. Tied to official X account hahacoinastar active since early 2024. Community and Activity Official X account hahacoinastar posts consistently about staking 15 percent plus APR via dApp burns airdrops and migration. Engagement is moderate. Web coverage is limited to Astar Soneium updates no scam alerts on trackers. Timeline active since February 2024 on Astar migrated January 2025 with ongoing development like LP burns and integrations. Potential Risks and Security Assessment Meme coins like HAHA are high risk due to volatility. Key risks include rug pull potential from unlocked liquidity and unrenounced ownership low liquidity for manipulation no formal audits and Soneium phishing. Creator 10 percent hold adds dump risk. Overall security is medium low positive active community burns ecosystem integrations negative centralization and transparency gaps. Recommendations for Buying Safely Verify contract 0xA8FeAae65C44B458A16Ea4E709036A2ee85d073A and QuickSwap on Soneium via Blockscout. Use hardware wallet revoke approvals avoid unverified links. Monitor hahacoinastar for updates check liquidity before buying start small. If concerned wait for locks or renounce or stick to audited projects. Report issues to Soneium scam lists. Data up to October 13 2025 crypto moves fast reverify before acting.

@Mouthmouth68 Based on risks detected today and previously: creator team left without explanation, creator hodls 10% of token supply 10 Trillion, Algebra pool on QuickSwap is probably unlocked which means liquidity could be removed. HAHA token contract has not clarity on renounced ownership leading to potential risks.

@Community_Council

I encourage the team to proceed with immediately delisting HAHA and suggest to blacklists the HAHA contract address on Soneium to protect investors and our community.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. Dennis